Stupid status question
Stupid status question
An L2 LC charges an L4 artillery. Ends in a draw what happens?
Re: Stupid status question
ART destroyed.... ![Sourire :)](./images/smilies/icon_e_smile.gif)
when it's a DRAW , ART always died except if ART have a better status..
Olivier M
![Sourire :)](./images/smilies/icon_e_smile.gif)
when it's a DRAW , ART always died except if ART have a better status..
Olivier M
Cordialement
Olivier M
Olivier M
-
- Sous-lieutenant
- Messages : 128
- Enregistré le : mer. 12 févr. 2020 22:56
Re: Stupid status question
Wait. But in this example the artillery does have better status; so it wins? Right?
Re: Stupid status question
No the ART have the same status " LINE" .
Status is only
I / M / L / E / G
Regards
Olivier M
Status is only
I / M / L / E / G
Regards
Olivier M
Cordialement
Olivier M
Olivier M
Re: Stupid status question
I ask because I just learned this
The status is used for combat and morale for fire
Thank you
The status is used for combat and morale for fire
Thank you
-
- Sous-lieutenant
- Messages : 128
- Enregistré le : mer. 12 févr. 2020 22:56
Re: Stupid status question
Wow is this correct? We have been using the combination of status + moral - so an L4 beats an L2. Frankly, this makes more sense to me but if that is not the rule . . .
-
- Chef de bataillon
- Messages : 384
- Enregistré le : ven. 29 nov. 2019 20:55
Re: Stupid status question
As I read it, compare morale first. So L4 beats L2 by 2.
If morale is equal compare status. E.g. E3 beats L3 by 1.
If morale is equal compare status. E.g. E3 beats L3 by 1.
- Talleyrand
- Lieutenant
- Messages : 177
- Enregistré le : dim. 6 janv. 2019 15:44
Re: Stupid status question
I agreeRogerGreenwood a écrit : ↑jeu. 27 août 2020 20:05As I read it, compare morale first. So L4 beats L2 by 2.
If morale is equal compare status. E.g. E3 beats L3 by 1.
combattu souvent, battu parfois, abattu jamais
Re: Stupid status question
This is also how the three of us have been doing this
It was pointed that the melee result compares status (this may be a translation issue?) and if the two are the same status L the cav or infantry win a melee against artillery(also on the cheat sheet on Facebook the word STATUS is printed in Caps and bold emphasizing status
Where as if you use the morale comparison an L4 beats an L2
Suddenly very unclear because if the word status in melee
If someone has the French version maybe it might make this clearer to understand
Walt the inquisitive
It was pointed that the melee result compares status (this may be a translation issue?) and if the two are the same status L the cav or infantry win a melee against artillery(also on the cheat sheet on Facebook the word STATUS is printed in Caps and bold emphasizing status
Where as if you use the morale comparison an L4 beats an L2
Suddenly very unclear because if the word status in melee
If someone has the French version maybe it might make this clearer to understand
Walt the inquisitive
Re: Stupid status question
Hi all,
i confirm that in french when you've got a DRAW, only the Status make the différence ( better status win or defender except for artillery who need a better status to win a draw)
However Moral différence is compared to give Bonus in melee OR status if the units got the same moral.
Regards
Olivier M
i confirm that in french when you've got a DRAW, only the Status make the différence ( better status win or defender except for artillery who need a better status to win a draw)
However Moral différence is compared to give Bonus in melee OR status if the units got the same moral.
Regards
Olivier M
Cordialement
Olivier M
Olivier M